Fred Phelps at his pulpit on August 4, 2002.

Fred Phelps at his pulpit on August 4, 2002. Photo courtesy Wikimedia Commons.

Several news agencies out of Kansas are reporting that Fred Phelps—founder of the infamous hate group Westboro Baptist Church—has died, citing a statement from one of his relatives.

Much will be made of his death, and some will surely celebrate it. I understand that impulse; years ago, as a deeply conflicted adolescent struggling greatly with being gay and a fundamentalist Christian, I felt the sting of his hateful words intimately.

But today, as an openly queer atheist, no part of me feels glad over his reported death. A sad and bitter life has ended, leaving behind a legacy of hate in its wake.

I have little to add to the chorus of voices condemning his years of dehumanizing anti-LGBTQ (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer) activism. They will find no disagreement from me.

But I will say this: the end of Fred Phelps is no victory. His group will continue its work, as will others opposed to LGBTQ rights. Those of us committed to promoting human dignity and compassion must continue ours.

The LGBTQ equality movement has demonstrated that people generally change their minds because of relationships, not shouting matches. Thus, Westboro Baptist Church’s work was doomed to fail from the start.

WBC and Phelps may have been good at getting attention, but they’ve largely failed to change hearts and minds in their direction. (If anything, they’ve made anti-LGBTQ views that much more unattractive.) May their utter failure to promote their vision of a divided world be a lesson to us all.

The consequences of that divided world are evidenced in the life of a man who was widely known of but not well-known. Phelps spent much of his life in a compound, largely interacting with those outside the bounds of his community through press releases and shouts offered across barricades and police tape.

Attempts to reduce the humanity of others cut us off from the world, reducing our own humanity in the process. Perhaps the legacy of Fred Phelps is not his anti-LGTBQ activism, but that his life serves as a perfect example of the isolating effects of hatred.

9 Comments

  1. Time to throw a party.

    If you are a supporter of WBC, think of it as a wake, mourning his passing.

    If you are not, think of it as celebrating that the world is a better place without his presence.

    • CarrotCakeMan

      A party is fine, but I hope no Americans try to disrupt his funeral the way he tried to disrupt so many Americans’ funerals. Americans shouldn’t stoop to the level of anti-gays.

      • http://www.religionnews.com/2014/03/20/fred-phelps-dies-america-tweets/#comments

        “Fred Phelps died, and the best thing we can do is picket his funeral with pies, cupcakes, and GOD LOVES EVERYBODY signs.

        — Chris Coletta (@chris_coletta) March 20, 2014″

  2. The Great God Pan

    I prefer the Westboro Baptist Church’s old-school, straightforward hatred to the carefully parsed, Slate Pitch-y “non-homophobia homophobia” practiced by the younger generation of Christian homophobes (Brandon Ambrosino, Damon Linker, Ross Douthat, Conor Friedersdorf, et al).

    With Phelps, what you saw was what you got. These Millennial ‘phobes are tricky and deceitful.

  3. There is very little in Fred Phelps behavior that looked like Jesus. I give him the benefit of the doubt that somewhere, somehow he sometimes looked like Christ. I pray for his soul.

    Its hard to pull a positive out of his life but at least one of them is that we know what a fundamental, legalistic, pharisaical person actually looks like.

    • Hey, don’t go tarnishing the good name of the Pharisees like that!

      (Among their other accomplishments, they gave us Rabbinical Judaism, from which almost all branches of present-day Judaism, from ultra-orthodox to humanist, ultimately descend.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments with many links may be automatically held for moderation.